Tonight as I headed home on ye public transit, I read through a portion of the book of Joshua. I was struck by the story of Achen, not because I hadn’t heard it before but because I hadn’t thought of it in terms of Federal Headship until now.
Federal Headship (to give a brief definition) is the idea that there are certain people appointed as representatives for others. Thus, the House of Representatives in the US Government as well as the US Senate are all modern political units that derrive from this idea of Federal Headship. In Scripture, the idea is mostly used in connection with Original Sin as we describe why it is that all of mankind was held responsible when Adam fell (and thus we are all born depraved). However, it’s also used by Paul in Romans 5 to demonstrate that our Federal Headship transfers to Christ when we become Christians.
In any case, knowing this structure, when I read the story of Achen I realized that this story also shows Federal Headship. Basically, what happens is that Israel attacked Jericho and God ordered them to destroy everything. Achen stole some of the items that were to be destroyed, and as a result the Israelites lost the next battle at Ai. Joshua then used lots to determine that it was Achen who had caused the problem. With that in mind, here are the key verses regarding the Federal Headship notion.
And he who is taken with the devoted things shall be burned with fire, he and all he has, because he has transgressed the covenant of the LORD, and because he has done an outrageous thing in Israel. (Joshua 7:15). This is the command of God as to what to do with the one who had taken the devoted things (that is, the items God wanted destroyed). The sentence included not only the one who caused the problem, but also “all he has.”
This is then carried out in the following passage:
And Joshua and all Israel with him took Achan the son of Zerah, and the silver and the cloak and the bar of gold, and his sons and daughters and his oxen and donkeys and sheep and his tent and all that he had. And they brought them up to the Valley of Achor. And Joshua said, “Why did you bring trouble on us? The LORD brings trouble on you today.” And all Israel stoned him with stones. They burned them with fire and stoned them with stones. (Joshua 7:24-25).
For the person who does not believe in Federal Headship, this is a very troubling passage. Indeed, I must confess that at first glance even I find this passage somewhat discomforting. Why was it that God commanded the death not only of Achen, but also his sons and daughters and all his livestock?
There is only one possible answer, and that is the idea of Federal Headship. When Achen sinned, he was not acting alone. He was acting as the representative of his family, and thus his entire family was condemned along with him.
But why would God do that? This is the question that troubles most non-Calvinists (who tend not to believe in Federal Headship). But in reality, this is no different from what God did in the Garden after He cursed Adam (and all his descendants after him). In fact, it illustrates how sins can be imputed to those who are not actually involved in the act itself. This is, in other words, a pre-cursor to the death of Christ. It is a picture (or a type) of the mechanism of how our sins are reckoned unto Christ and His righteousness unto us.
Any other interpretation of this passage must, in my opinion, lead to the idea that God capriciuosly and maliciously decided to act out vengance on innocent people. Only if they were legally declared unrighteous could God have commanded their death specifically for the sin of Achen with impunity. Naturally, God could have condemned them for their own sins without anyone raising a fuss; but the passage is clear that Achen’s sons and daughters were killed due to Achen’s sin. How is that possible with a just and righteous God? The only answer is if Federal Headship is valid.





